Tribunal and commission updates from India's specialist legal forums.
The NGT Central Zone Bench dismissed 23 appeals by Bharatpur sandstone miners challenging environmental compensation of approximately Rs 4.6 crore imposed by the Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board.
The NGT Central Zone Bench dismissed appeals by 23 Bharatpur sandstone miners challenging RSPCB show-cause notices and environmental compensation totalling approximately ₹4.6 crores for EC condition violations.
NCLAT Principal Bench finds no pre-existing dispute where the corporate debtor itself prepared and signed a consequence sheet quantifying the undisputed amount owed to the operational creditor.
The Bangalore Bench resolves five substantive disputes for Atria Convergence Technologies for AY 2016-17, allowing goodwill depreciation and non-compete depreciation while remanding connectivity charges and network acquisition.
The Pune Bench set aside separate additions on gross on-money receipts and Section 69A peaks, directing the Assessing Officer to recompute income using a single chronological peak credit ledger.
The Principal Bench held that reconstructing a leave account post-retirement without a show-cause notice and denying LTC benefit on a pre-scheme advance payment were both legally unsustainable.
NCDRC holds IFFCO-Tokio's 2012 repudiation of a machinery breakdown claim invalid, finding the insurer had knowledge of the rotor swap through broker communications and pre-inspection.
The Competition Commission found the Director General's comparisons of hospital prices with hotel tariffs and standalone diagnostic labs methodologically flawed, closing the Section 4 case against Apollo Hospital.
The Competition Commission of India closed Case No. 77(7) of 2015 against Fortis Flt. Lt. Rajan Dhall Hospital, finding the DG's aftermarket abuse findings unsustainable on evidence.
Ahmedabad ITAT remands on-money additions against Popular Group sellers, holding a handwritten loose sheet without cash trail or corroboration cannot sustain section 69A additions.
Four candidates who cleared all stages of North Eastern Railway's 2007 Group D selection but were placed only in the 20% replacement panel have had their appointment claim dismissed by CAT Allahabad.
The Competition Commission of India closed a decade-long inquiry against Max Super Specialty Hospital, Patparganj, finding the Director General's methodology for establishing unfair pricing under Section 4 legally insufficient.
Thirteen candidates on the 20% extra replacement panel of a 2007 North Eastern Railway Group D recruitment sought appointment; CAT Allahabad dismissed the original application after the select list's life had ended.
The NGT Central Zone Bench dismissed a challenge to Rajasthan's Nagaur District Survey Report and related mining lease, holding the application was time-barred, non-maintainable, and an efficacious alternate remedy existed.
The NGT Central Zone Bench dismissed 23 appeals by sandstone mining leaseholders in Bharatpur, upholding environmental compensation imposed by the Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board under the Air Act.
Fourteen candidates who cleared all stages of North Eastern Railway's 2007 Group D recruitment failed to secure appointment; CAT Allahabad finds no illegality in vacancy surrender and holds Dinesh Kumar Kashyap inapplicable.
Twelve candidates on the 20% extra replacement panel of a 2007 North Eastern Railway recruitment sought Group D appointments; CAT Allahabad dismissed the application finding the select list had expired and key precedents inapplicable.
The NGT Central Zone Bench dismissed 23 appeals by Bharatpur sandstone miners challenging environmental compensation totalling approximately Rs 4.6 crore imposed by the Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board.
ITAT Hyderabad sets aside assessments for AY 2022-23 and AY 2023-24, finding the order time-barred and third-party seized material insufficient to sustain additions under Section 56(2)(x).
The Principal Bench dismissed appeals by the resolution applicant and erstwhile RP, finding that delays of many months in refiling the plan approval application left liquidation as the only option.
APTEL refused to condone a 421-day delay in restoring an electricity appeal, holding the Successful Resolution Applicant failed to show sufficient cause after the moratorium ended.
The Competition Commission of India has closed a decade-long inquiry against BLK Max Super Specialty Hospital, finding the DG's evidence insufficient to establish unfair pricing under Section 4 of the Competition Act.
The NGT Central Zone Bench dismissed appeals by 23 sandstone mining leaseholders in Bharatpur, Rajasthan, upholding environmental compensation imposed by the Rajasthan State PCB for violations near the Taj Trapezium Zone.
NCLAT's Principal Bench set aside NCLT's admission of Canara Bank's Section 7 application against Equinox India Developments, finding the corporate guarantee covered equity infusion only and the application was barred by Section 10A.
